Reviewer ResourcesJournal of Applied Robotics and Artificial Intelligence
Access structured checklists and reporting guidance for robotics and AI manuscripts.
Resources for Reviewers
JRAI provides review templates, ethics guidance, and reporting standards to support consistent evaluations.
Guidelines and Checklists
Resources include summaries of CONSORT, STROBE, and PRISMA where relevant, plus structured review prompts.
Support and Assistance
Contact the editorial office for help with review forms or deadlines.
Request Reviewer Tools
Email the editorial office for access to reviewer resources.
Email the Editorial OfficeView Reviewer GuidelinesEmail: [email protected]
JRAI Commitment
We prioritize clear decision making, ethical oversight, and consistent editorial standards for the robotics and AI community.
Review Templates
Structured templates guide comments on methodology, results, and conclusions, helping reviewers deliver consistent feedback.
Reporting Guidelines
Quick links to CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, and AI reporting resources support compliance checks.
Statistical Checks
Guides highlight common statistical pitfalls and recommended reporting practices.
AI Evaluation Checklist
Checklists cover dataset splits, external validation, and bias assessment for AI models.
Robotic Safety Checklist
Safety prompts focus on device reliability, failure modes, and human factors.
Ethics Guidance
Ethics notes cover consent, privacy, and animal welfare requirements.
Example Reviews
Sample reviews illustrate tone and structure expected for major and minor revisions.
Data Availability Support
Instructions explain how to evaluate data and code availability statements.
Deadline Management
Guidance helps request extensions or decline when deadlines cannot be met.
Contact Support
The editorial office is available to answer questions about policies or review forms.
Continuous Updates
Resources are updated to reflect new standards in robotics and AI publishing.
Structured Scoring
Some reviews use scoring grids to rate novelty, methodology, and clinical relevance. Use scores to reinforce narrative feedback.
Ethics Quicklist
Ethics quicklists summarize consent requirements, data privacy checks, and animal welfare statements. These prompts reduce missed compliance issues.
Figure Review Tips
Guidance explains how to assess image quality, manipulation risks, and figure labeling. Use it when results rely on imaging or device outputs.
Reference Libraries
Suggested reference libraries highlight foundational robotics and AI methods. They help reviewers assess whether claims are supported by prior work.
Review Timeline Checklist
A checklist helps plan time for reading, analysis, and writing the report. It supports on time delivery.
Statistical Aids
Quick tips cover effect sizes, confidence intervals, and common reporting errors. Use these aids when statistical sections are unclear.
Data Sharing Guidance
Notes explain acceptable repositories and citation formats for datasets and code.
Review Tone Examples
Examples demonstrate respectful wording for critical feedback and help maintain a professional tone.
Follow Up Support
Editors can clarify review expectations or extend deadlines when needed.
